Propositional logic, truth tables, and predicate logic. Its true that whether every mathematical theorem is a tautology depends on the notion of tautology being used. It will actually take two lectures to get all the way through this. For example, amritsar is the capital of india in table 6. Proof by contradiction is also possible with young children. The scientific method uses contradiction to falsify bad theory. A contradiction is any statement of the form q and not q. In the worst case, the proof method may take just as many or more steps to find an answer as the truth table method. My teacher says that if all your hypotheses and your conclusion are not tautologies, you can do the proof. Prove the following statement by contradiction there is no greatest even integer.
A proposition is satisfiable if it is not a contradiction. A contradiction is a proposition that is always false e. The compound statement p p consists of the individual statements p and p. Here are two tautologies that involve converses and contrapositives. Jul 12, 2019 a proof by contradiction is often used to prove a conditional statement \p \to q\ when a direct proof has not been found and it is relatively easy to form the negation of the proposition. Similar to modus ponens, modus tollens is based on the tautology. A tautology can be verified by constructing a truth tree for its negation. Weve got our proposition, which means our supposition is the opposite. Jul 25, 2019 tautology, contradiction and contingency. A propositional formula is valid or a tautology it is true for all possible interpretations. How to prove a tautology using proof by contradiction. In a course that discusses mathematical logic, one uses truth tables to prove the above tautologies. A logical basis for the contradiction method of proof is the tautology.
The opposite of a tautology is a contradiction or a fallacy, which is always false. Leron 1985, for example, observed that despite the simple and elegant form of certain. Proof by contradiction wikimili, the free encyclopedia. Truthtables,tautologies,andlogicalequivalences mathematicians normally use a twovalued logic. Since we have shown that p f is true, it follows that the contrapositive tp also holds. Indicate if each of the following propositions is a tautology, a contradiction, or a contingent proposition. The advantage of a proof by contradiction is that we have an additional assumption with which to work since we assume not only \p\ but also \\urcorner q\. Proof by contradiction this is an example of proof by contradiction. Propositional logic propositional resolution propositional theorem proving unification today were going to talk about resolution, which is a proof strategy. Tautologies, contradictions, contingencies 64 as you will learn later, the propositional form p. Mathematical proofs are, in a sense, the only truly absolute knowledge we can have. The sum of two positive numbers is not always positive. A proof by contradiction is a proof that works as follows.
When the truthtable method of proof is used, however, everyone can see. Tautology, contradiction, contingent flashcards quizlet. Tautology contradiction contingency satisfiability propositional logic gate net part 6. Proof by contradiction california state university, fresno. Yet research has shown that students experience difficulties with proof by contradiction in mathematics. Proving a compound proposition is a tautology part 1 of 2 kailee gray. Propositional equivalences tautologies, contradictions, and contingencies.
Prove that if you pick 22 days from the calendar, at least. In the truth table above, p p is always true, regardless of the truth value of the individual statements. Use proof by contradiction to show that, given a rational number a and an irrational number b, a. If assuming a false sentence prevents us from arriving at any coherent truth. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. Only when the possibility of p and p having the same truth value is excluded, can the conclusion, p and p, be demonstrated. Propositional logic, truth tables, and predicate logic rosen. A contingency is a proposition that is neither a tautology nor a contradiction. A proposition is said to be a tautology if its truth value is t for any assignment of truth values to its components.
Use the laws of logic to show that the following logical expression is a tautology without the truth table. A propositional formula is contradictory unsatisfiable if there is no interpretation for which it is true. Use a proof by contradiction to give a proof that v2 is. For many students, the method of proof by contradiction is a tremendous gift and a trojan horse, both of which follow from how strong the method is. In other words, a contradiction is false for every assignment of truth values to its simple components.
The sum of two positive numbers is always positive. State what the negation of the original statement is. In logic and mathematics proof by contradiction is a form of proof that establishes the truth or validity of a proposition by showing that assuming the proposition to be false leads to a contradiction. Discussion the rst two methods of proof, the \trivial proof and the \vacuous proof are certainly the easiest when they work. Math, im in an advanced math class in sixth grade, and were doing logic proofs. Concerning the laws of contradiction and excluded middle. If you are given any statement or argument, you can determine if it is a tautology by constructing a truth table for the statement and looking at. Assume to the contrary there is a rational number pq, in reduced form, with p not equal to zero, that satisfies the equation. To prove p, assume p and derive a contradiction such as. Some of the examples were left as exercise for you.
Hardy pictured below, he describes proof by contradiction as one of a mathematicians finest weapons. Chapter 6 proof by contradiction mcgill university. A stronger foundation for computer science and p np. No matter what the individual parts are, the result is a true statement. The hypothesis is false, therefore the statement is vacuously true even though the conclusion is also false. Simplest examples of a contingency, a tautology, and a. Truthtable definitions of a tautology, a contradiction, a contingency 16 5. However, its hard to see how any plausible notion of tautology will apply to all mathematical theorems. Most statements are neither tautologies nor contradictions.
From this assumption, p 2 can be written in terms of a b, where a and b have no common factor. Start studying tautology, contradiction, contingent. What were trying to show is that this is a contradiction. The previous truth table also shows that the statement \\urcorner x \to c\ is logically equiva lent to \x\.
Part of the problem here may be that tautology has a far more specific meaning in mathematical logic than in ordinary usage. This method sets out to prove a proposition p by assuming it is false and deriving a contradiction. A tautology is a compound proposition that is always true. A proposition is said to be a contradiction if its truth value is f for any assignment of truth values to its components. A contradiction is a compound proposition that is always false. To prove a statement p is true, we begin by assuming p false and show that this leads to a contradiction. Proof by contradiction is used in mathematics to construct proofs. In my last video we have seen converse, inverse and contrapositive of an implication and its examples. D is a tautology b d b b v d d f a tautology will never be false, so if we plug in a value of f for the main connective and get a coherent truth assignment for b and d, we know that the sentence can be false, and so cannot be a tautology. First, well look at it in the propositional case, then in the firstorder case.
An alternative proof is obtained by excluding all possible ways in which the propositions may fail to be equivalent. The compound statement p qp consists of the individual statements p, q, and pq. In fact, the apt reader might have already noticed that both the constructive method and contrapositive method can be derived from that of contradiction. Proof by contradiction is also known as indirect proof, proof by assuming the opposite, and reduct. This tautology shows that if \\urcorner x\ leads to a contradiction, then \x\ must be true. If you not still watched that video, please watch that video before watching this video. In that proof we needed to show that a statement p. Assume the statement is false, show that this assumption entails a contradiction, then negate the assumption. This tautology, called the law of excluded middle, is a direct consequence of our basic assumption that a proposition is a statement that is either true or false. The use of this fact forms the basis of the technique of proof by contradiction, which mathematicians use extensively to establish the validity of a wide range of.
So, this is probably a silly approach to this sort of thing, but i hate truth tables and take a slightly more circuitous route through what quine referred to as alternational normal form. The opposite of a tautology is a contradiction, a formula which is always false. Proof by contradiction in logic and mathematics is a proof that determines the truth of a statement by assuming the proposition is false, then working to show its falsity until the result of that assumption is a contradiction. Leron 1985, for example, observed that despite the simple and elegant form of. Sep 03, 2016 use the laws of logic to show that the following logical expression is a tautology without the truth table.
Many of the statements we prove have the form p q which, when negated, has the form p. The proof began with the assumption that p was false, that is that. This means that if we have proved that \\urcorner x\ leads to a contradiction, then we have proved statement \x\. For a set of premises and a proposition, it is true that. Prove by contradiction that there is no greatest even integer. A compound proposition is satisfiable if there is at least one assignment of truth values to the. A compound statement, that is always true regardless of the truth value of the individual statements, is defined to be a tautology. Alternatively, you can do a proof by contradiction.
Its a principle that is reminiscent of the philosophy of a certain fictional detective. Tautology is sometimes symbolized by vpq, and contradiction by opq. The metaphor of a toolbox only takes you so far in mathematics. A a tautology when there is a proof by contradiction. In fact, the apt reader might have already noticed that both the constructive method and contrapositive method can.
A logical statement which is neither a tautology nor a contradiction is a contingency. A contingency is neither a tautology nor a contradiction. Mathematical proofmethods of proofproof by contradiction. In fact, the logical forms of logically true propositions are tautologous. Here, in other words, the law of contradiction is used to prove itself. State you have reached a contradiction and what the contradiction entails. Tautology contradiction contingency satisfiability. Argument clinic, a monty python sketch in which one of the two disputants repeatedly uses only contradictions in his argument. Suppose by contradiction that there is a greatest even integer. To prove p, assume p and derive a contradiction such as p.
Hence a contradiction and a tautology are a negation of each other. Proof by contradiction from edexcel sample papers 1. Proof by contradiction also known as indirect proof or the method of reductio ad absurdum is a common proof technique that is based on a very simple principle. Nov 15, 2017 tautology contradiction contingency satisfiability propositional logic gate net part 6. Moreover, proofs are usually much smaller than the corresponding truth tables. You must include all three of these steps in your proofs.
377 1449 1341 850 1022 423 274 1508 208 427 691 1068 1070 652 1254 386 717 1186 1351 275 296 1035 421 1243 1267 658 1304 1379 410 78 1463 833 179 1319